In the world of animal lovers, choosing between a collar and a harness for your dog is a hotly debated and passionate topic. We often find ourselves faced with conflicting advice, fueling the dilemma: which is the best tool for the well-being and safety of our four-legged friend?

In reality, the answer is not unequivocal. There is no one training method that is more correct than another , but only the combination that best suits the specific needs of the dog and the situation .

Let's immediately dispel a common myth : A harness doesn't solve the problem of dogs pulling on the leash . In fact, in some cases, it can actually make the situation worse . Harnesses were originally designed as a tool for sled dogs to pull; therefore, designed for this purpose, they make pulling on the leash easier. The harness doesn't teach the dog how to walk; it simply distributes the force differently. The real work in training a dog to enjoy a walk without pulling must begin with the relationship established between dog and owner, with patience, positive reinforcement, consistent training, and attention to its needs.

How to choose, then? The key is to observe your dog and his habits :

- Dogs that pull on the leash: In this case, it's essential to teach the dog to walk on the leash using dog training methods based on positive reinforcement. A harness, while it may seem like the simplest solution, doesn't address the root of the problem and can actually reinforce it. In these situations, it's helpful to consult an expert to understand the dog's motivation for pulling on walks (is it fear, or excessive stimulation? There could be many different reasons), and be wary of anyone who offers a training tool as a solution .

- Dogs with respiratory or neck problems: In this case, a harness can be a good option, as it avoids putting pressure on the neck. However, it's important to choose an H-harness , the only one that allows adequate movement for the animal, distributing pressure evenly across the chest and shoulders. Other types of harnesses could cause discomfort and compromise the dog's posture and proper mobility.

- Shy or fearful dogs: The neck is a point of communication for dogs, frequently used by their peers. For this reason, some dogs struggle to tolerate constant pressure on this area, and in this sense, the H-harness can convey a sense of security and comfort thanks to its soft, enveloping feel. Likewise, since the body is rarely used as a point of communication, other dogs may dislike the harness for this reason and be more comfortable with a collar.

- Puppies: For puppies, a soft, lightweight collar is generally recommended , given their constant growth. A harness may not fit their ever-changing body shape properly and cause discomfort, as well as compromising proper bone and muscle development.

- Dog sports : Some dog sports require the use of a harness, while others require a collar. For this reason, it's important to ask your instructor which training equipment is best for the sport you're interested in.

And what about the leash? Here too, the choice ranges from classic models to more technical ones, such as adjustable leashes. Generally speaking, it's important to opt for a sturdy leash that's well-proportioned to the dog's size , with a comfortable handle for a secure grip.

In our online store, you'll find a wide selection of handcrafted collars, harnesses, and leashes, crafted in Italy from the finest materials, with your dog's well-being in mind. Each product comes with a detailed description and recommendations for choosing the right one for your furry friend. If you still have any questions, please contact us! We'll be happy to answer all your questions and help you make the best choice for you.

Remember: there's no universal rule. The important thing is to choose carefully , based on your dog's characteristics and habits, and don't hesitate to seek advice from your experienced dog trainer or educator .

With a little attention, the right equipment, and a relationship based on respect and positive reinforcement , you will experience happy and safe walks with your faithful adventure companion!